CFDs Explained: What They Are, How They Work and What They Cost
Contracts for difference explained simply: how you win and lose, the role of leverage, hidden costs and the protections for European clients.
What CFDs are, in plain words
A CFD (contract for difference) is an agreement between you and the broker: you exchange the difference between an instrument's price when you open the position and its price when you close it. If the price moves in your favour you receive the difference; if it moves against you, you pay it.
The key point is that a CFD does not make you the owner of the underlying asset. If you open a CFD on a company's shares you do not become a shareholder, you have no voting rights and you hold no securities: you are only speculating on the price. That is why CFDs let you trade many markets (currencies, indices, shares, commodities, cryptocurrencies) from the same account and platform.
CFDs are traded over the counter (OTC), not on regulated exchanges: your counterparty is the broker itself. This makes choosing an authorised and supervised broker essential, because the broker's soundness is part of the risk.
How a CFD works: long and short examples

With a CFD you can open a position in either direction. If you think the price will rise you go long (buy); if you think it will fall you go short (sell). Being able to profit from falling prices is one reason CFDs are so popular, but the reverse also holds: you can lose either way.
Long example: you buy 10 CFDs on a share priced at €100, worth €1,000. If the price rises to €105 and you close, the result is +€50 (€5 × 10), before costs. If it falls to €95 instead, the result is −€50.
Short example: you sell 10 CFDs on the same share at €100. If the price falls to €92 and you close, you make €80 (€8 × 10); if it rises to €108, you lose €80. Theoretical risk is higher on a short, because a price can rise far more than it can fall.
Leverage and margin: the heart of the risk
CFDs are leveraged products: to open a position you do not pay its full value, only a part of it called margin. With 1:5 leverage on a share, a €10,000 position requires €2,000 of margin. Leverage multiplies your exposure, so it multiplies gains and losses on the capital committed in the same way.
Back to the example: if the share falls 10%, the €10,000 position loses €1,000, i.e. 50% of the €2,000 margin. At that point the automatic close-out required by European rules kicks in: when available funds fall to 50% of the required margin, the broker closes positions to limit losses. A 10% market move has turned into a 50% loss on the capital invested.
For retail clients in the European Union the maximum leverage is set by ESMA's measures, applied by national authorities such as Consob and CySEC:
| Underlying | Maximum leverage | Minimum margin |
|---|---|---|
| Major currency pairs | 1:30 | 3.33% |
| Other currencies, gold, major indices | 1:20 | 5% |
| Commodities (excluding gold), minor indices | 1:10 | 10% |
| Individual shares and other underlyings | 1:5 | 20% |
| Cryptocurrencies | 1:2 | 50% |
Limits for retail clients. Professional clients can get higher leverage but give up some protections.
What CFDs cost: spreads, commissions and swaps
The most visible cost is the spread, the difference between the buy and sell price: as soon as you open a position you start slightly in the red because of it. Some brokers add a fixed commission per trade or per lot in exchange for tighter spreads; others include everything in the spread.
The cost that surprises beginners most is overnight financing (swap). Because leverage means using capital provided by the broker, every night the position stays open you pay interest calculated on the full position value, not just the margin. At a hypothetical 7% annual rate, a €10,000 position costs about €1.90 a day: little for a trade lasting a few days, a lot for one held for months. That is why CFDs are designed for short-term trading.
Also consider currency conversion when the instrument is priced in a different currency from your account, any inactivity fees and, for shares, dividend adjustments: long positions are credited with the dividend amount, short positions are debited.
Protections for European clients
Since 2018 ESMA has set specific rules for CFDs sold to retail clients, now applied permanently by national authorities. Besides leverage limits, they require automatic close-out at 50% of margin, negative balance protection (you cannot lose more than the money in your account), a ban on bonuses and incentives to trade, and a standard risk warning.
The risk warning states the percentage of retail client accounts that lose money trading CFDs with that broker. When it introduced these rules, ESMA found that between 74% and 89% of retail accounts were losing money. It is the single most important figure to read before you start: it tells you most traders lose.
CFDs vs real shares: the differences
CFDs and real shares may look alike because they follow the same price, but they serve different purposes. Real shares suit long-term investing; CFDs suit short-term speculation, up or down.
| Feature | Share CFDs | Real shares |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership of the security | No | Yes |
| Voting rights | No | Yes |
| Dividends | Cash adjustment | Received as a shareholder |
| Leverage | Yes (up to 1:5 for EU retail) | No (unless margin lending) |
| Short selling | Yes, simple | Complex or unavailable |
| Holding cost | Daily swap | None (except any custody fees) |
| Suitable horizon | Short term | Medium to long term |
Which markets you can trade with CFDs
The practical advantage of CFDs is access to many markets from a single account: currency pairs (forex is the most traded market), stock indices such as the DAX, FTSE MIB or S&P 500, shares listed on major exchanges, commodities such as gold, oil and gas and, with some brokers, cryptocurrencies with maximum leverage of 1:2.
More markets does not mean more opportunities for everyone: each underlying has different trading hours, volatility and costs. Beginners are better off focusing on a few instruments they understand.
Advantages and risks of CFDs
The advantages: you can trade rising and falling prices, leverage lets you open positions with less capital, you reach many markets from one account and entry costs are low. Risk-management tools such as stop loss and take profit help you decide in advance how much you are willing to lose.
The risks: leverage can quickly wipe out much of your capital; swaps make holding positions for long periods expensive; prices can gap past your stop loss after news or a weekend, so the stop fills at a worse price; and your counterparty is the broker. Negative balance protection stops your account going below zero, but it does not stop you losing all the money you deposited.
Are CFDs right for you?
Before letting you trade, a European broker must give you an appropriateness test on your knowledge and experience. If the result says CFDs are not appropriate for you, the broker must warn you: take that warning seriously.
CFDs can make sense for people who understand how leverage and margin work, spend time on analysis, always use a stop loss and only invest money they can afford to lose. They are not suitable for building long-term savings, for anyone seeking guaranteed returns, or for those who cannot monitor open positions.
How to start carefully
Step one is choosing a broker authorised in the EU, checking its licence on the supervisor's website (Consob, CySEC or another European authority). Then use the demo account, with virtual money, until you have a tested strategy and fully understand the platform and its costs.
When you move to a live account, start with small amounts, use less leverage than the maximum allowed and do not risk more than 1-2% of your capital on a single trade. A trading journal helps you understand what works and what does not.
Finally, remember that CFD profits are taxable. If you are an Italian tax resident using a foreign broker, you must calculate and pay the tax yourself: see our guide to trading taxes in Italy for details.
Frequently asked questions
Are CFDs legal in the EU?
Yes. CFDs are legal financial instruments in the EU and can be offered by firms authorised by a national regulator such as Consob or CySEC, including across borders under the EU passport. ESMA's restrictions on leverage, margin and negative balance protection apply to retail clients.
Can you lose more than you invest with CFDs?
Not as a retail client of an EU-regulated broker: negative balance protection prevents your account from going below zero. You can still lose all the money you deposited, and with leverage that can happen quickly.
What is the difference between CFDs and shares?
With shares you own the securities, receive dividends and have voting rights. With a share CFD you only bet on the price change: you can use leverage and go short, but you pay a swap for every night you hold the position and you own nothing.
Are CFDs suitable for beginners?
They are complex instruments and most retail accounts lose money. A beginner should study first, use the demo account for a long time and, if they decide to trade, start with small amounts, low leverage and a stop loss on every trade.
How is the swap on CFDs charged?
The swap is automatically debited (or in some cases credited) to your account for every night the position stays open, and it is calculated on the full position value. On forex a triple swap is usually applied on Wednesday to cover the weekend.
How are CFDs taxed in Italy?
For Italian tax residents, CFD gains are “redditi diversi di natura finanziaria” taxed at 26%. Losses can be offset against gains of the same kind over the following four years. With a foreign broker they must be reported in section RT of the tax return, together with section RW for tax monitoring.